Sunday, December 14, 2014

Exodus: Gods And Kings

2.5 Stars (out of four)

I really, REALLY wanted this movie to be good.  And it is on some levels.  The story of Exodus is sweeping in scope and makes for great drama, never mind its biblical implications.  This is one of those stories that reverberates across the years because of its importance to the modern-day world.  Whether or not you believe in the Bible, the story of Moses cannot be denied due to its impact on today.  All three major religions accept it and it is arguably the beginning of Israel as a kingdom and now nation with all that that entails.  The movie was in the very capable hands of Ridley Scott, a director who, time and again, has proven to be a master storyteller of huge, epic tales.  I won't go into a plot synopsis because unless you have been under a rock your whole life, you know the story of Moses.  So what, exactly, went wrong with this film?

Well, let's first look at what went right.  It is a grand retelling of Exodus, with real scope and majesty.  The special effects are spectacular and convincingly portray the large events in Exodus, from the plagues to the parting of the Red Sea.  Everyone in the cast is great, with Christian Bale's portrayal of Moses and Joel Edgerton's Ramses as incredible standouts.  As they are the heart of the film, these performances were crucial, and if they didn't work, the movie falls apart.  There are large, expansive sets and scenes and spectacles that take your breath away, and Scott's great eye for capturing these moments was spot on.  The movie is big and ambitious and hits the mark for showmanship.

But what goes wrong with the film are the small parts.  Inevitably, this film will draw comparisons to The Ten Commandments, but it really should have tried for the beating heart of the animated The Prince of Egypt.  Exodus: Gods and Kings is so preoccupied with its epic scope, it forgets the drama of what is actually happening right in front of you.  A theme I was forced to return to again and again as I watched this film was intimacy, or rather, the lack of it.  The film has been taking its fair share of abuse from critics and audiences by saying it is essentially Gladiator (another Ridley Scott film) meets Moses.  The emphasis on action cheapens or totally obscures the real messages of the story, the whole reason to tell it in the first place.  While Ridley Scott is good at telling historical drama, most of his movies are fictitious painted against tableaux of real historical events (Gladiator, The Kingdom of Heaven, 1492: The Conquest of Paradise).  There are a lot of compelling things in Exodus.  Putting aside God for a moment, there are two powerful cousins as close as brothers ripped apart due to competing loyalties to each other and their motivations; Moses' exile and return to Egypt; Moses' story of his divided heritage; his adoption of a new culture and family far different from his upbringing; his discovery of his true identity and the effect that has on him; Ramses' divided loyalties between his brother and his responsibilities as Pharoeh; the actual exodus of the Jews out of four hundred years of slavery.  All of the things make for great drama, and none of them are addressed with any real emphasis other than the exodus itself.

All this potential great drama seems peculiarly cold and detached in the movie.  A good example is Moses' wedding night.  Before the consummate their marriage, we see the Moses and Sephora telling each other what their love means to each other in an oddly stilted manner, as if they are rehearsing wedding vows.  Compare this to the wedding night of Braveheart where in the morning, William Walkace's wife dresses him.  With this simple act, there is a very warm and human intimacy between the two that powerfully illustrates the deep love they have for each other.  While I don't doubt Moses loved his wife just as much, the scene just feels contrived.  They fall in love because the script says so, and now let's get back to the action in progress as quickly as possible.  The movie is replete with failed opportunities like this for us to connect with any of the characters on any human level with the exception of Ramses, who gets the most sympathetic treatment I've have ever seen of him.  In The Ten Commandments, for the most part, Yul Brynner has to play him almost as a comic book villain.  In Exodus, it is the exact opposite.  Ramses' character feels as one whom things are being heaped upon unfairly and elicits more than a small bit of sympathy.  In fact, he comes across as the most rational character in the story.

But for me, and for most people who will see this film, the most important, and glaring issue, is the almost complete omission of God.  The whole movie seems to be interested in demystifying the entire exodus story, to the point where God almost has no part in it at all.  And when he does show up, He is played as a petulant child by a very young actor (in one of the most bizarre plotline device and casting choices in movie history). Now, while it is true the God of the Old Testament is very different in actions from the God of the New, it is almost jarring how annoying they make Him here.  The God of the Old Testament tends to be more wrathful while the God of the New more loving in his actions.  But in this movie, God is most interested in revenge and retribution.  He scolds Moses time and again for his hesitancy to act, yet when Moses asks him, quite reasonably, why God has waited 400 years to act and why the urgency now, God lashes back at him in a hissy fit.  Then when Moses does act in an ultimately doomed insurgency, God tells him to sit down and shut up and begins the plagues.  Gone are any confrontations between Moses and Pharoeh and his court.  Gone are any indications that Moses is speaking for God at all.  In fact, the whole movie suffers from the Raiders of the Lost Ark story problem: Moses is incidental to anything that happens in the exodus.  It all happens despite him, and he is not an active participant in the events, so he has no effect on their outcome.  It is as if the filmmakers were so interested in telling a "realistic" and scientific version of the events (an admittedly interesting and apologetic idea), they forgot the deeper reason to tell the story in the first place: that is God actively helping establish a new nation for his Chosen People.  I know labels like this are scary to modern revisionists who don't believe in God, but this IS the reason for the story.  And while this movie is light years better than last year's spectacular crapfest Noah, Exodus: Gods And Kings still misses the mark. Is it worth watching?  Yes.  The movie should be told on an epic scope in a theater.  But ultimately, it will leave you unfulfilled as a story.  An interesting, but ultimately failed idea in the final analysis.


The November Man

2.5 Stars (out of four)

I really had high hopes for this film.  As a huge James Bond fan, this actioneer promised some pretty neat thrills and chills, a kind of James Bond meets Jason Bourne kind of thing.  The movie certainly delivers on the action.  The plot, well, that's another story entirely.

The November Man opens with a CIA team led by a very English-sounding Devereaux (Pierce Brosnan) leading a CIA team on a mission to protect the U.S. Ambassador in Montenegro from assassination.  Part of the team is Devereaux's protogė Mason (Luke Bracey).  Mason is still being trained to be an operative and although the mission is a success, Mason's impetuousness results in a child being killed.  We then fast forward 8 years to the present where we find Devereaux has retired and is running a cafe in Switzerland.  An old boss and friend visits him one day and asks for help in getting a source out of Russia, one of Devereaux's old cases.  This is an unsanctioned mission as the source is targeted for assassination by a CIA team, led by who we find out later to be Mason.  Devereaux accepts the assignment out of a personal responsibility he feels to protect her, but he fails.  But before she dies, she tells him there is a plot between a high-level CIA person and the Russian president-elect.  This sets off a dangerous cat-and-mouse game between Devereaux and the CIA, with the fate of the world in the balance.

As I have said many times in the past, story is everything.  Everything else can be right, but if the script is bad, the movie suffers no matter how good everything else is in the film (Star Wars prequels anyone?).  The sad thing is, this movie actually has great potential.  The story is sound and engaging. It has a couple of twists that are fun, and unlike many other films of this type, has something to say regarding issues of real importance today that seem to get forgotten.  In this case, one of the big underlying issues is the problem of human trafficking in Eastern Europe in particular.  A key witness was abducted for two years and she holds the key to CIA/Russia nexus.  But as good as the setup is, it goes off the rails quickly in the telling.  The problem is that the movie is not very good at exposition.  We are dropped right in the middle of a very complicated story without any real background on the motivations of anyone in the film and this leads to a lot of confusion.  The movie instead prefers to let us in on important details as surprise plot twists which, instead of being the point where you shout out, "Aha!  It all fits now!" to just further muddying the plot.  In this movie, motivations are extremely important to understand why things are happening.  Devereaux is on a kill-crazy rampage to try to find out why the source was killed in Russia.  He also seems very interested in humiliating Mason and helping him alternatively.  Mason, for his part, is alternatively trying to kill Devereaux and helping him.  It doesn't make a whole lot of sense.  It's as if the scriptwriters were writing as they go, making more and more preposterous leaps.

It's too bad this movie falls kind of flat.  There are some good stories in here.  If they would stick to one or two, it probably would have been a superior movie.  As it is, it is worth watching, but in the end, pretty disappointing from the letdown of how good it promised to be.


Tuesday, December 9, 2014

The Purge

2.5 Stàrs (out of four)

Considering The Purge's progeny (Paranormal Activity and Sinister, both very good horror films), I expected quite a bit when I sat down to watch it.  I have been holding off watching the movie for some time, thinking it would not be very good, and I was partially correct.

Thè Purge takes place in the near future in a rich suburbanite town.  America has a unemployment and violent crime rate that hovers somewhere around 1%.  This is because there is some new quasi-theocratic government running the United States, and every year, for 12 hours, the purge occurs.  As some kind of natural catharsis, all crime is legal, and all police and emergency services are suspended.  It is a sort of government-supported anarchy that theoretically gets the beast out of everyone by letting them fulfill their darkest desires.  The specific story is about a wealthy family who, during the purge, let in a homeless man who was wounded by some very unlikeable young punks who want to kill him for sheer sport.  They threaten the family that if they do not release the man, they will break in and kill everybody.  Eventually they do break in, but another twist throws a monkey wrench in those plans..,

So.  This is not exactly an original story.  Star Trek had an episode entitled Return of the Archons which was essentially the exact same scenario except it was called the Red Hour instead of the Purge.  In either case, both shows were making points about the thin veneer of civilization that covers our very brutal souls.  Each show suggests it will not take much to let that beast out.  They also posit that if everyone were able to live out their darkest fantasies of raping and killing anything they see for a certain period of time, that this will have some kind of therapeutic effect on a population.  Since Stár Trek comes from a much more optimistic worldview on human nature, Kirk says no to those inner demons, while acknowledging their existence.  He is on the side of civilization, and how that civilization is crucial to us as human beings.  Perhaps because we now live in a more cynical age, The Purge, while saying there may be unintended consequences to this activity, it will still go on.  Now, the movie is not suggesting this is an ideal set of events; far from it, actually.  But it does suggest it is a possible scenario.

As I stated before, this movie was brought to us by the same people who made the superior horror film Sinister, and like Sinister, it is filled with very disturbing imagery, especially when you consider the age of the perpetrators in both films.  But while Sinister is an unapologetic horror film that is very bleak, The Purge is attempting to be something more.  It is attempting to be a social commentary of sorts, in its own extremely ham-handed way.  The movie alternately posits that this is the natural outgrowth of a government based on religious principles.  It also a very class-conscious vehicle.  The homeless man is, of course, black and poor, and his attackers are privileged, white young people.  The film also says that the purge was made to eliminate the poor class as they do not have the means to defend themselves with sophisticated home defense systems.  So the movie is a white/black-rich/poor war scenario that seems straight out of The Turner Diaries.  And while I do applaud the writers for actually trying to say something more profound than a horror film, the philosophy behind it could be written by a twelve-year-old and has all the depth of a mud puddle.  It is obvious and brutish at every turn, and the final twist is mildly clever, but ultimately predictable.  It's The Stepford Wives meets Psycho, but has neither of these shows' understated nuance (yes, there is nuance in Psycho).

In the end, it comes down to the fact that the filmmakers were shooting for something profound and ultimately produced something hackneyed.  But they are to be commended for at least trying to say something, as we live in a jaded and apathetic time where moral relativism reigns.  It is trying to sound a warning klaxon in its own plodding way.  Like Paranormal Activity and Sinister, it is chock full of very disturbing and threatening imagery that is quite effective, making this a cut above its slasher kin.  But ultimately, it's the story that matters, and it falls a bit flat in this case.  It's disappointing really, considering how good the other two are.  They can't all be winners, I guess.  Now let the horrible sequels commence!


Monday, December 8, 2014

Foxcatcher

 3 Stars (out of four)

Foxcatcher was one of those films that is getting a lot of good press, but I am not so sure it deserves all the press it gets.  Most of the critics loved it, but I am so-so about it.

The story is actually pretty simple.  Based on true events, Channing Tatum and Mark Ruffalo play Mark and David Schultz, a champion brother wrestling team (both were Olympic gold medalists) who joined Team Foxcatcher, a team sponsored by John E. DuPont from the DuPont family for the 1988 Seoul Olympics.  Events take an unexpected turn with tragic results.

Based on a true story.  One critic wisely said those are some of the most dangerous words in cinema.  Obviously movies are not documentaries, nor are filmmakers historians, nor should they be.  But those five simple words have caused more misunderstandings of historical events because of the dictates of good storytelling.  But because of those five words, it gives any filmmaker a free pass on what they decide to show or use the story to push their political agenda under the guise of "It's not my fault.  It's a true story."  Because of the perceived realities of film, people take these stories literally and it causes a group misconception.  Shows like Argo, Blackhawk Down, and We Were Soldiers, with their differing levels of liberties taken with people and events make me question the authenticity of any of these stories now.  And now, since these types of stories are becoming so ubiquitous, it no longer seems like any of them have any shred of truth.  It gives the filmmakers a crutch in my opinion, a lazy way out on taking a stand.  Yet they still fascinate because of those five little words.

The movie itself is fine.  It is quite fun to see Steve Carrell plays such an oddly menacing guy.  It is such a departure over his usual fare.  While Carell is a gifted comedian, I have found comedians tend to make some of the best actors out there.  Steve Martin, Gene Wilder, Robin Williams, Jim Carrey, Tom Hanks.  I think the reason they all make such good actors is that they have to be hyper aware of what they do for comedy.  Every nuance, every gesture, every tic, every inflection can kill what would otherwise be a good joke.  This hyper-awareness of themselves is precisely the same kind of skill that is required for good acting to be convincing, especially since good comedy tends to be an inflated sense of reality and must be real enough to be convincing.  That said, the movie is, in the movie vernacular, "deliberately paced."  Most normal people would call it slow.  I have been seeing that the movie is getting a lot of accolades for all the acting, but the overarching theme of the movie seems to be awkward silence.  The whole movie seems to be based on nobody saying much.  There are no dramatic confrontations, no fast-paced action, and therefore a tad boring.  It is an interesting story, but this is something that can wait to rent.


Saturday, November 29, 2014

Birdman or (The Unexpected Virtue of Ignorance)

3 Stars (out of four)

I have been complaining for a long time that Hollywood has no original ideas left.  Boy, was I wrong.  I must say, while I have seen the techniques of this film before, I have never seen their combination pulled off so deftly.

Michael Keaton plays Riggan, a washed-up, superhero actor who is trying to overcome several obstacles to produce a Broadway play that he wrote to restore some of his former prestige, or at least relevance.  He has left a trail of wreckage from his past that he is trying to fix, as well as overcome all the problems that occur just before a play premiers.  He is trying to repair his relationship with his estranged daughter Sam (Emma Stone) as well as his former wife Laura (Andrea Riseborough).  He, along with his best friend Jake (an almost unrecognizable Zach Galifinackis) have to deal with accidents and hiccups to bring out a play that is teetering on failure before it even starts.  After a freak accident injures their leading man the day before the first preview, they hire Mike (Edward Norton), an incredibly gifted, popular, but self-centered actor who may destroy the show.  Finally, they must deal with the biggest problem, will anyone actually come to it?

Writer/Director Alejandro Gonzáles Iñárritu has pulled off something great here.  Mark my words, you will see him win either best Director or Screenplay from this film.  The film, as I said before, is all technique.  It is a mishmash of Waiting for Guffman, Rope, and just about every screwball comedy you have ever seen with a heavy dose of pathos for atmosphere.  The movie is told with everything from aplomb to zest.  It starts slow and deliberate, but as the pressure mounts, the movie's action and dialogue gets more and more frenzied to by the time we hit the climax, almost everyone is yelling and running.  One of the neat filmmaking techniques in here is that it is told as if it was caught in one long tracking take, which was done previously by none other than the great Hitchcock himself in Rope.  This continuously moving camera gives a documentary feel to the story.

The actual story takes place over about a week and melds fantasy and reality seamlessly, almost too much so.  It is sometimes very difficult to know where reality ends and fantasy begins in this story, especially in its enigmatic Lady or the Tiger-ish ending.  We see most of the story through Riggan's eyes and his cinematic superhero alter ego Birdman, whom we hear speak to Riggan in his mind.  Riggan also has superpowers that manifest themselves during the film.  Is he really Birdman, or is it all in his mind?  We never really know since no one sees him do these things until the end when Sam sees him flying?  We don't know.  The film is never clear.  Keaton's performance in this is so good.  He should have had an Oscar 26 years ago with the movie Clean and Sober, and he has never turned in a bad role from Mr. Mom to Beetlejuice to Pacific Heights to Jackie Brown and yes, even Batman, which this film unapologetically references through Birdman.  He will no doubt be nominated, but I don't know who else was better than him this year.  Maybe this is finally his time.  It is long overdue.  But Keaton isn't the only great performances here.  Galifinackis is wonderfully restrained, a welcome change to his man-child character of The Hangover.  Emma Stone is the perfect, cynical and damaged suicide girl with just the right amount of vulnerability.  And Edward Norton is as amazing as ever with his Method-immersing Mike.

The hardest part for me in this film, however, is what it is condemning or extolling.  It is a love story to the theater and a poison pen letter to its illegitimate bigger brother, cinema.  It seems to extol the theater as the place for real artists, and film as the toxic dump where art goes to die to be replaced by commerce.  Yet it also condemns the theater for giving into film's siren song of cash by taking on the very stories of film it is supposed to be above.  This is a not-so-subtle dig at recent Broadway fare like The Lion King, The Producers, and most obviously, Spider-Man: The Musical.  The attitude of the theater crowd is reflected in Tabitha, the aging theater critic.  She is determined to kill Riggan's play in its crib for no other reason other than it stands for everything she hates; from privileged actors who have no business on Broadway with "real" actors, the cheapening of art in favor of stylistic themes in theater, to the cynical cash-grab from plays that have no artistic merit from her eyes.  

This is the classic conflict of the art versus the pop world.  What is more important--art or commerce?  The answer, of course, is both, and those who understand that are usually branded as sell-outs.  The "serious" art world is very small and pompous and in love with its self-perceived ability to understand things the philistines cannot.  That is why great artists like Norman Rockwell to Andy Warhol to Banksy will never be considered great artists by the arbiters of taste because they appeal to the common person's sensibilities, and that offends them.  That is why they prefer The Iceman Cometh to Jackson Pollack to Federico Fellinni to Miles Davis as opposed to Phantom of the Opera to Stan Lee to Alfred Hitchcock to Lady Gaga.

Ultimately, Birdman is a really good film, almost great.  It has something interesting to say in a very interesting way.  It is trying to be big like a blockbuster while keeping its art film soul.  It will not be everybody's cup of tea, but I, for one loved it an would recommend it to just about anyone who wants something meaty to chew on thematic-wise.  For all you film geeks out there, there is a lot to love as well with the aforementioned technique.  I think you will be surprised.  Check it out.




Big Hero 6

3 Stars (out of four)

This was a lot of fun, and I didn't expect it to be, which just made it that much better.  Disney has been pushing this film for so long, and telling us absolutely nothing about it, that it was saturating the market.  It turns out I shouldn't have worried, because John Lassitar was at the helm and he has saved Disney from itself by backing fabulous stories like he did when he headed Pixar.

Big Hero 6, based on the Marvel comic (another Disney property.  Ironic, isn't it?) takes place in the not-so-distant future in the city of San Fransokyo.  The main character is Hiro, a young robotics genius who is a bit of a layabout until his older brother,Tadashi, convinces him to enter a robotics contest for a scholarship to the school he goes to.  Hiro enters with a groundbreaking robotics design and wins.  But there is a fire in the building and Tadashi ends up perishing in an explosion.  Hiro is understandably heartbroken by this and one day accidentally turns on Baymax, Tadashi's invention of a robotic nurse that looks like a big balloon.  Hiro realizes that someone has stolen his invention and is using it for nefarious ends, so he convinces Tadashi's friends to form a super team based on their individual scientific talents to stop the bad guy.  They, with an upgraded Baymax, then go to save the day.  Like many very original stories, there is obviously a lot more to this story, but I don't want to give too much away.

In a recent interview in Wired! magazine, John Lassitar gives his maxim for a great movie, whether it be live or animated: no matter how good the premise is, the characters must be believable and relatable for the movie to resonate with audiences.  This is a basic truth with good storytelling anytime; that because we are seeing it unfold through his eyes, the protagonist is our anchor to the events of the story and helps us suspend disbelief for it by making him or her relatable.  In other words, we like the main character, we tend to buy the story no matter how weird it is.  This is especially crucial in sci-fi and fantasy, two genres whose odd environments require this suspension.

John Lassiter is responsible for pretty much every successful Pixar movie until he started to work as the head of Disney's animation department.  Once he started at Disney with the movie Bolt, there is a dramatic uptick in the quality of Disney films that have been lacking since Mulan, when Jeffrey Katzenberg left.  It is ironic that Disney did not learn from Katzenberg's example of what makes stories work, and has taken Lassitar to reteach these lessons to them.  In both cases, Disney was the pioneer in animation, but that animation just became the money machine, with the dollar taking precedence over the story, and in each case, they could not produce an interesting or entertaining movie.  Compare Oliver & Company to The Little Mermaid or Treasure Planet or Lilo & Stitch to Frozen.  It is night and day.

Big Hero 6 has a lot of great themes running through it.  Dealing with grief, the importance of family and friends, and more importantly, forgiveness.  It makes heroes out of the geeks, a trend that I, a proud geek, am glad to see.  I wish they had these films when I was a kid.  In any case, is this Disney's best film?  Not really.  But it is excellent and funny and totally entertaining.  I would recommend it for anyone.


Dumb and Dumber To

2 Stars (out of four)



Well, there is a problem with high expectations.  Usually, they get dashed against the wall.  I went into this sequel to the fantastic Dumb and Dumber with the exact opposite attitude I went into the first one, and it turns out one hurts a lot worse than the other.

There really isn't a lot to Dumb and Dumber To if you have already seen the first.  We get the continuing adventures of Lloyd (Jim Carrey) and Harry (Jeff Daniels), two of the dumbest nitwits alive.  After being in a mental asylum for twenty years as a goof, Harry and Lloyd resume their lives.  It turns out Harry finds out he is a father, but he got the notification 22 years too late.  When Lloyd sees her picture, he falls in love (or more accurately, in lust) with Harry's newfound daughter.  This sets them off on a trip which brings the madcap duo back to the screen.

When I saw Dumb and Dumber for the first time, I almost had to be dragged there at gunpoint.  I was on vacation, didn't want to see a movie, and worse yet, had been purposefully avoiding this one because it looked so...well, dumb.  As it turned out, it was one of the funniest films I have ever seen.  A film I can still watch today and bust a gut laughing (turbo lax?).  The combination with my hating the possibility of seeing it with the heat of 10,000 suns and just how incredibly funny it actually was made for one of the most sublime movie experiences I have ever had.  After the movie was a hit, the two leads went onto bigger and better things and never looked back.

Well, I guess Carrey and Daniels needed the paycheck because it's twenty years later and we're back to the past.  Now, to be fair, the movie has two or three incredibly funny jokes in it that save it from total mediocrity.  Unfortunately, that is not enough to make this a film worth the $13 it will cost you to see it.  A friend put it perfectly.  When they did the first film in their mid 30s, it was edgy stuff that was great and original.  Fast forward twenty years, and they are now in their mid 50s, and the jokes just seem mean.  He hit the nail on the head.  The film's chief, and possibly fatal, flaw is that it either assumes you never saw the first one or that you like ironic self-reference a LOT.  They must have really liked every single joke they wrote in the first movie, because they are all rehashed in this one.  Don't believe me?  Check out the teaser posters:


Now, as a rule, there is nothing wrong with a little self-reference.  In fact, it can be quite funny if it builds on the joke.  But, like cilantro, a little goes a long way.  The problem is when that self-reference is the essence of the movie, especially a comedy, it constantly reminds us that you are out of good, or at least original, ideas.  Then the question becomes why should we watch this when the original is so much better?  While there are many factors that make humor funny, I would argue one of the most important is spontaneity, the fact we don't see the joke coming.  And that is the chief problem with Dumb and Dumber To; you see all the jokes coming because you've already seen them once before.  And the end result is not a comedic masterpiece, but rather seems like a cynical retread to separate us from our money.  The producers and writers didn't even work that hard at it.  They said "Let's just do the same damn thing we did before and the stupid public will eat it up."  Carrey and Daniels are both in fine form and try their best to save this film, but sadly for them, in this case, lightning did not strike twice.