2 Stars (out of four)
The movie abruptly changes tone from action flick to prison drama to revenge flick to Grindhouse over-the-top actioneer. The story doesn't make a lot of sense and keeps adding characters and wrinkles that should have been brought out earlier. It is pretty intense at times, too. This IS Mel Gibson, after all, the creator of the bloodbaths Braveheart, We Were Soldiers and Apocalypto. But also like those films, it is engaging. This movie could have been horrible in lesser hands. It's sort of Escape From New York meets Lockup, and holds more than a few similarities to another one of his films, The Payback. And while it does tilt, it never goes completely off the rails. Like it or not, Mel has charisma to spare and it helps immensely in this film. And while he has aged quite badly, he still pulls off the film. It is schlock, yes, but he has a long way to go if moviegoers will ever take him back, if ever.
A big complaint I have, though, is that it is genuinely unsettling at times at the type of violence in the film. While I am no prude for any story element being in a film, whether it be nudity, violence or whatever, there has to be a reason for it. It cannot be included for its own sake; otherwise it is just gratuitous. There is a subplot where the kid Mel works with is an exact blood type match for the ruler of the prison. The kid is being kept alive for his liver for a later transplant. Well, the time eventually comes, but not before the bad guys torture his mother and he stabs himself to ruin the liver. We also get to see the surgery in detail. As this is going on, I'm asking myself, "Is this REALLY necessary?". If I'm asking myself that, chances are, it probably isn't. There is also a slow motion shoot out that, while exciting, several innocent bystanders are wounded or killed in the crossfire. While this does prompt the denouement of the Mexican government shutting down the prison, this is not exactly the type of scene I expect from American moviemakers. Maybe that is the point. It seems more at home in a over-the-top Chinese actioneer like Hard Boiled or The Killer and totally out of place here.
Hey! I liked Plan 9! :-D
ReplyDeleteYes, it does have a goofy charm. How about Showgirls, then?
ReplyDelete