1 Star (out of four)
Forest Gump said "Life is like a box of chocolates. You never know what you're gonna get.". The same is true for Rob Zombie movies. He's made some great films (The Devil's Rejects, Halloween), awful films (Halloween 2), and over-the-top ridiculous films (House of 1000 Corpses). But the two things I've always admired about his films is they are a.) ostentatious but well-crafted, and b.) he does NOT think horror films are misunderstood comedies. He actually thinks they should be scary in a horrifying kind of way, not a jump-out-and-shout-BOO! kind of way. Rob, like me, grew up with horror films that had a nihilistic streak a mile wide. The monster did not spout awful jokes and they did NOT end on a happy note. Compare the seminal films of the late 60's through early 80's. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre, Halloween, Friday the 13th, The Hills Have Eyes, Suspirio, The Exorcist, Carrie, The Shining, Night of the Living Dead, Dawn of the Dead, The Omen, Rosemary's Baby. All of them intense, scary, and not a joke to be seen anywhere. They were endured, not enjoyed. Rob, so far, has subscribed to this story-telling mechanism for his films. And they, for the most part, have been really good. So I went into The Lords of Salem with great anticipation for another good scare.
But..
What I got was probably the most pretentious college student film ever made. Imagine if the worst nightmares of Torquemada, H.P. Lovecraft, H.R. Giger, Dean Koontz, Anton LeVay, Marilyn Manson, David Lynch and Ozzy Osbourne were vomited together into a stew and had a little blasphemy all stirred in for a little flavor, and you will have a good idea of the experience of The Lords of Salem. Kids should like it because it will freak out their parents and their parents will hate it, but anyone even possessing half a brain will see how stupid it is. Now, Rob Zombie's art has never been what anyone would call subtle, but this is just ridiculous. He is trying to out-devil The Exorcist, but it really just comes across as over-the-top buffoonery. Worse yet, it is actually well-made. Zombie has an eye for good direction, so what is supposed to be scary just comes off as pretentious. He's trying too hard to be outrageous, and therefore has made an unscary horror film. It's almost as if Steven Spielberg or Martin Scorsese suddenly made Plan 9 From Outer Space. It is that jarring. The only thing I can say is good about the film is the music is appropriately moody, courtesy of Zombie's guitarist, John 5, and that it is well-crafted. The problem is the story stinks. It makes absolutely no sense, hits every devil-movie cliche there is, and is just plain dumb. Zombie breaks my cardinal rule for any film: Never put in anything for its own sake. Everything must serve the story. Rob is so preoccupied with being outrageous here that he forgets to actually think about quality. Maybe outrageousness is the only way to make a dent in our desensitized psyches anymore, but plain old horror still works. Witness the like of The Seventh Sense, Se7en, or The Silence of the Lambs. All disturbing stories, but all great. Zombie is capable of these heights. I've seen it. I just wish he could consistently achieve them.
Thursday, April 25, 2013
Tuesday, April 23, 2013
Oblivion
2 Stars (out of four)
Tom Cruise's newest film, Oblivion, has some good points and bad. First, the good. It is a beautiful movie, a visual feast for the eyes. There is rarely a boring moment as far as visuals go. The director who made this film also made Tron 2. And this is where the film goes off the rails. Tron 2 was also an incredibly interesting film for the eyes, but a fairly dull story. Oblivion has a good, but slow story. It's too bad, because the film's story has potential. The reveal at the end is quite good. Unfortunately, the film is what most critics call "deliberately paced," which is critic-ese for boring.
I like dystopian future movies. They are interesting, although a tad depressing. It is always interesting to see what people think the future will be like. It is just one of my quirks. I love The Omega Man, Waterworld, Escape From New York, The Terminator, all of them. Oblivion is a lot like Kevin Costner's The Postman. Both movies are actually pretty good, but take just a little too long to get to their respective denouments. It's too bad, because I really thought Oblivion was going to be good. I wanted it to be good, but it just falls a little short of the mark. I am not talking about the actual story because I don't want to give anything away. If you are going to see this film, you really do want to see it in a theater. It would lose a lot on a small screen. In the end, it's a lot of fun to watch, but it is a tad boring. There's really not a lot to say more about this film, I'm sorry to say. I know the review this time is short, but there really is not much else to say. Not great, but not bad.
Tom Cruise's newest film, Oblivion, has some good points and bad. First, the good. It is a beautiful movie, a visual feast for the eyes. There is rarely a boring moment as far as visuals go. The director who made this film also made Tron 2. And this is where the film goes off the rails. Tron 2 was also an incredibly interesting film for the eyes, but a fairly dull story. Oblivion has a good, but slow story. It's too bad, because the film's story has potential. The reveal at the end is quite good. Unfortunately, the film is what most critics call "deliberately paced," which is critic-ese for boring.
I like dystopian future movies. They are interesting, although a tad depressing. It is always interesting to see what people think the future will be like. It is just one of my quirks. I love The Omega Man, Waterworld, Escape From New York, The Terminator, all of them. Oblivion is a lot like Kevin Costner's The Postman. Both movies are actually pretty good, but take just a little too long to get to their respective denouments. It's too bad, because I really thought Oblivion was going to be good. I wanted it to be good, but it just falls a little short of the mark. I am not talking about the actual story because I don't want to give anything away. If you are going to see this film, you really do want to see it in a theater. It would lose a lot on a small screen. In the end, it's a lot of fun to watch, but it is a tad boring. There's really not a lot to say more about this film, I'm sorry to say. I know the review this time is short, but there really is not much else to say. Not great, but not bad.
Friday, April 12, 2013
Evil Dead (1983) vs. Evil Dead (2013)
1983 Version-2.5 Stars (out of four)
2013 Version-1Star (out of four)
Well, it may have happened. Hollywood is now officially out of new ideas. The new iteration of Evil Dead, is, in a word, awful. Now, I know many of you out there are slapping your heads and saying, "Well, what the hell did you expect? It is Evil Dead, after all." I would first say that yes, you're probably right about that. But, when you watch the original, it's so bad, so bloody, so amateurish, you can't help but sort of love it in a strange, but conspiratorial way. I actually watched the original again to refresh my memory. You can tell from its stupid, disjointed story, the over-the-top extreme gore (I can honestly say that the original is one of the goriest movies I have ever seen), the crappy synthesizer music, the generally cheap look of it all; that a very talented group of young, college students were trying to make their mark. The DIY look and feel of the original gives it a subversive vibe, but in the end, it has a witty charm to it. A wink-and-a-smile, a knowing grin that says we are all in on the joke. The filmmakers themselves say in the DVD commentary they were out to simultaneously mock the horror films of the day and yet make a new type of horror the surpasses everything yet made up to that point. They even stick in the poster for The Hills Have Eyes to say, you think you know horror? This is real horror. Many of the alumni from the original went on to great careers of their own including cult favorite Bruce Campbell, Sam Raimi, and Joel Coen. So, objectively, the original is not that great, but this is art, and subjectively, it's a lot of fun if you don't take it too seriously.
Now, the new one, it's just bad. The sad thing is,the setup would make a good film. The reason they are in the cabin is that the first victim is a recovering junkie. The rest are her friends and estranged brother who brought her there so she can get away from the temptations where she is from so she can kick her habit cold turkey. This, in itself, would be a great movie with real drama. As it turns out, the egghead of the group finds the evil book, stupidly reads it DESPITE the fact it tells him not to, and the dead rise and wreak havoc, blah blah blah. The rest of the film is an exercise in gory excess with wooden characters and stupid situations. The setups are predictable and cliche. The original is bad, but charming. This is just bad. The problem is, is that good, studio professionals made this one. At least the original has an excuse for being bad. The young guys didn't really know what they doing. The new one is like Michaelangelo doing finger paints. Instead of crappy synth music, there's an orchestra. Instead of stupid, rubber prosthetics, there's very realistic gore effects. Instead of dropping the characters into a dumb story, this tries to add backstory, also bad. It's only saving grace is that it at least the story is comprehensible that has the potential to be good. It's just an exercise in condescending excess. The producers feel their audience is stupid and not discerning, and they will buy any old crap. Don't waste your time with this and rather go see the original instead.
2013 Version-1Star (out of four)
Well, it may have happened. Hollywood is now officially out of new ideas. The new iteration of Evil Dead, is, in a word, awful. Now, I know many of you out there are slapping your heads and saying, "Well, what the hell did you expect? It is Evil Dead, after all." I would first say that yes, you're probably right about that. But, when you watch the original, it's so bad, so bloody, so amateurish, you can't help but sort of love it in a strange, but conspiratorial way. I actually watched the original again to refresh my memory. You can tell from its stupid, disjointed story, the over-the-top extreme gore (I can honestly say that the original is one of the goriest movies I have ever seen), the crappy synthesizer music, the generally cheap look of it all; that a very talented group of young, college students were trying to make their mark. The DIY look and feel of the original gives it a subversive vibe, but in the end, it has a witty charm to it. A wink-and-a-smile, a knowing grin that says we are all in on the joke. The filmmakers themselves say in the DVD commentary they were out to simultaneously mock the horror films of the day and yet make a new type of horror the surpasses everything yet made up to that point. They even stick in the poster for The Hills Have Eyes to say, you think you know horror? This is real horror. Many of the alumni from the original went on to great careers of their own including cult favorite Bruce Campbell, Sam Raimi, and Joel Coen. So, objectively, the original is not that great, but this is art, and subjectively, it's a lot of fun if you don't take it too seriously.
Now, the new one, it's just bad. The sad thing is,the setup would make a good film. The reason they are in the cabin is that the first victim is a recovering junkie. The rest are her friends and estranged brother who brought her there so she can get away from the temptations where she is from so she can kick her habit cold turkey. This, in itself, would be a great movie with real drama. As it turns out, the egghead of the group finds the evil book, stupidly reads it DESPITE the fact it tells him not to, and the dead rise and wreak havoc, blah blah blah. The rest of the film is an exercise in gory excess with wooden characters and stupid situations. The setups are predictable and cliche. The original is bad, but charming. This is just bad. The problem is, is that good, studio professionals made this one. At least the original has an excuse for being bad. The young guys didn't really know what they doing. The new one is like Michaelangelo doing finger paints. Instead of crappy synth music, there's an orchestra. Instead of stupid, rubber prosthetics, there's very realistic gore effects. Instead of dropping the characters into a dumb story, this tries to add backstory, also bad. It's only saving grace is that it at least the story is comprehensible that has the potential to be good. It's just an exercise in condescending excess. The producers feel their audience is stupid and not discerning, and they will buy any old crap. Don't waste your time with this and rather go see the original instead.
Saturday, April 6, 2013
Dazed and Confused (1993)
3 Stars (out of four)
Dazed and Confused does what all great art should do, evoke a feeling. I didn't see this film when it first came out, and that's probably a good thing. If I would have seen this in my 20s when it came out, it would have gone over my head. The movie is about the last day of school in 1976 and what the kids do in an unnamed town in the U.S. There is no nostalgia, no ruminations on how great it was back then, just what was. Unlike American Graffitti, this isn't a longing look back at our teens and how great or bad those times were, a remembrance with rosy glasses. Nor is it The Breakfast Club, which, when I saw it, spoke to me on a deep level, that the writers understood what I was thinking at the time. It is simply what was, bored teens looking for a good time, waiting for something to happen and, whether they know it or not, waiting for their lives to start with no idea what lies ahead. While I was not a teen of the 70s, nor was drinking my scene, as I watched the film, some feelings came through. The memories of tmy teens, it all came back in a rush. That feeling that something was ahead, that our lives were ahead of us. But it was also tinged with sadness knowing what it is like on the other side. It's been said that youth is wasted on the young. I never really knew what that meant until recently. While my life is not bad, it certainly isn't everything I expected or wanted at that age. The point of all this is that is precisely what art should do, evoke feelings.
While nothing really happens in the film, it is wonderful. It's really fun to watch to see so many future stars in some of their earliest roles including: Ben Affleck, Milla Jovovich, Adam Goldberg, Matthew McConaughey, Parker Posey, and Joey Lauren Adams. For me, it's always fun to see where they started. While this movie may not be for all tastes, it's a lot of fun. It will take anyone back as there are certain experiences that are universal to us all.
Dazed and Confused does what all great art should do, evoke a feeling. I didn't see this film when it first came out, and that's probably a good thing. If I would have seen this in my 20s when it came out, it would have gone over my head. The movie is about the last day of school in 1976 and what the kids do in an unnamed town in the U.S. There is no nostalgia, no ruminations on how great it was back then, just what was. Unlike American Graffitti, this isn't a longing look back at our teens and how great or bad those times were, a remembrance with rosy glasses. Nor is it The Breakfast Club, which, when I saw it, spoke to me on a deep level, that the writers understood what I was thinking at the time. It is simply what was, bored teens looking for a good time, waiting for something to happen and, whether they know it or not, waiting for their lives to start with no idea what lies ahead. While I was not a teen of the 70s, nor was drinking my scene, as I watched the film, some feelings came through. The memories of tmy teens, it all came back in a rush. That feeling that something was ahead, that our lives were ahead of us. But it was also tinged with sadness knowing what it is like on the other side. It's been said that youth is wasted on the young. I never really knew what that meant until recently. While my life is not bad, it certainly isn't everything I expected or wanted at that age. The point of all this is that is precisely what art should do, evoke feelings.
While nothing really happens in the film, it is wonderful. It's really fun to watch to see so many future stars in some of their earliest roles including: Ben Affleck, Milla Jovovich, Adam Goldberg, Matthew McConaughey, Parker Posey, and Joey Lauren Adams. For me, it's always fun to see where they started. While this movie may not be for all tastes, it's a lot of fun. It will take anyone back as there are certain experiences that are universal to us all.
Sunday, March 31, 2013
Killing Them Softly
2 Stars (out of four)
Brad Pitt's newest movie, Killing Them Softly, is a mystifying movie. At times, it is one of the best crime films I have seen in recent years. At other times, it is annoying and confusing. The movie starts where two half-witted guys stick up a mafia card game and make away with $50,000. Brad Pitt, a contact killer, is called to kill both of them. He later calls James Gandolfini (Tony Soprano if you didn't know), a fellow killer to help with the job. Gandolfini then goes on an alcoholic and whoring binge and then inexplicably disappears from the film. Brad Pitt kills all the bad guys and demands payment. The end.
If that seems abrupt, the movie does that a lot. This being a movie from the Weinstein Company, it has to be arty, and this movie attempts to be just that. First, I'll get I to what I liked about the movie. It gets onto the gritty aspects of being in the mob. It does not gloss over any of the gruesome aspects of being in the criminal element. Movies like Goodfellas and The Godfather, while excellent, tend to glamorize the criminal life. In Killing Them Softly, there is absolutely nothing glamorous about any of the characters. All of them are dim-witted, dull and stupid. What is even better about it is that most of the actors have played iconic mob roles. In the vein of not glamorizing anything, the scenes of violence are some of the most visceral I have ever seen. The violence is gruesome and cruel, nothing cool about it. I, for one, think cartoonish violence is not a healthy thing. It should be portrayed as it is, ugly and destructive. Otherwise, it both loses it's dramatic punch and desensitizes us to its impact.
What I didn't like about the film was, first, it's abruptness. The movie literally ends when Brad Pitt demands payment for what he has done. The movie also tries too hard. It is trying to be arty, and it shows. I have made it a point to say that there should be nothing in a movie for its own sake. In this case, it is art for art's sake, sacrificing story for sentiment and making some kind of message. The filmmakers are obviously trying to say something, but it is unclear what. The movie attempts to be deconstructionist, but it fails miserably at this, as well. It was done much better in Clint Eastwood's masterpiece, Unforgiven. Finally, there was a specific element that annoyed me to no end. Throughout the movie, which takes place during the McCain/Obama election, we keep hearing snippets from the news totally unrelated to the story. It prattles with Bush speaking on the state of the economy and politicos saying how bad the economy is. There is also inappropriate music in the soundtrack, using very old and time/subject inappropriate tunes. The movie ends on a cynical take on the cut-throat business environment of the U.S. This is probably the point of all the news snippets, but who knows? Anyway, not a great mob movie, or movie movie for that matter.
Brad Pitt's newest movie, Killing Them Softly, is a mystifying movie. At times, it is one of the best crime films I have seen in recent years. At other times, it is annoying and confusing. The movie starts where two half-witted guys stick up a mafia card game and make away with $50,000. Brad Pitt, a contact killer, is called to kill both of them. He later calls James Gandolfini (Tony Soprano if you didn't know), a fellow killer to help with the job. Gandolfini then goes on an alcoholic and whoring binge and then inexplicably disappears from the film. Brad Pitt kills all the bad guys and demands payment. The end.
If that seems abrupt, the movie does that a lot. This being a movie from the Weinstein Company, it has to be arty, and this movie attempts to be just that. First, I'll get I to what I liked about the movie. It gets onto the gritty aspects of being in the mob. It does not gloss over any of the gruesome aspects of being in the criminal element. Movies like Goodfellas and The Godfather, while excellent, tend to glamorize the criminal life. In Killing Them Softly, there is absolutely nothing glamorous about any of the characters. All of them are dim-witted, dull and stupid. What is even better about it is that most of the actors have played iconic mob roles. In the vein of not glamorizing anything, the scenes of violence are some of the most visceral I have ever seen. The violence is gruesome and cruel, nothing cool about it. I, for one, think cartoonish violence is not a healthy thing. It should be portrayed as it is, ugly and destructive. Otherwise, it both loses it's dramatic punch and desensitizes us to its impact.
What I didn't like about the film was, first, it's abruptness. The movie literally ends when Brad Pitt demands payment for what he has done. The movie also tries too hard. It is trying to be arty, and it shows. I have made it a point to say that there should be nothing in a movie for its own sake. In this case, it is art for art's sake, sacrificing story for sentiment and making some kind of message. The filmmakers are obviously trying to say something, but it is unclear what. The movie attempts to be deconstructionist, but it fails miserably at this, as well. It was done much better in Clint Eastwood's masterpiece, Unforgiven. Finally, there was a specific element that annoyed me to no end. Throughout the movie, which takes place during the McCain/Obama election, we keep hearing snippets from the news totally unrelated to the story. It prattles with Bush speaking on the state of the economy and politicos saying how bad the economy is. There is also inappropriate music in the soundtrack, using very old and time/subject inappropriate tunes. The movie ends on a cynical take on the cut-throat business environment of the U.S. This is probably the point of all the news snippets, but who knows? Anyway, not a great mob movie, or movie movie for that matter.
Saturday, March 23, 2013
Olympus Has Fallen
2.5 Stars (out of four)
Olympus Has Fallen looks like a big, loud and stupid movie, and that is exactly what it is, except that it is a hoot as well. I wasn't expecting much, and I wasn't disappointed. The movie is about a group of North Korean terrorists who take over the White House and make various demands. The only man who stands in their way is Gerard Butler, an ex-special forces secret service agent who somehow gets into the White House after the bad guys get in and gives them all a bad day. If this is beginning to sound like Die Hard or Air Force One, I'm sure it is a coincidence.
My question is, why does it seem so impossible for an American actor to play an American hero in an American action film? Batman, Lincoln, The Walking Dead, Thor, Blackhawk Down, Taken, the list goes on. Did American actors just suddenly become a bunch of sissies? There is nothing wrong with their performances, it's just where did all the actors go? Morgan Freeman plays his usual old, father-figure in charge. I only have two complaints about this film. First, most movies that have the President as a hostage seem to think the rest of the government would just lie down and capitulate. They seem to forget that we have continuity in command in our government. While we do not relish the idea of our chief executive as a hostage, we are not a dictatorship or monarchy. Our society and government will go on. The terrorists at one point make ridiculous demands and the government just gives in to save the President. This would never happen. I realize it is just a movie, but there are limits to my disbelief. The other is that director Antoine Fuquoi shoots most of the movie in the dark, so it is difficult to see what is going on and therefore the action tends to be confusing. Also, since it is confusing, it tends to not be very exciting.
So, overall, it is a fine romp, but it is not exactly a masterpiece.
Olympus Has Fallen looks like a big, loud and stupid movie, and that is exactly what it is, except that it is a hoot as well. I wasn't expecting much, and I wasn't disappointed. The movie is about a group of North Korean terrorists who take over the White House and make various demands. The only man who stands in their way is Gerard Butler, an ex-special forces secret service agent who somehow gets into the White House after the bad guys get in and gives them all a bad day. If this is beginning to sound like Die Hard or Air Force One, I'm sure it is a coincidence.
My question is, why does it seem so impossible for an American actor to play an American hero in an American action film? Batman, Lincoln, The Walking Dead, Thor, Blackhawk Down, Taken, the list goes on. Did American actors just suddenly become a bunch of sissies? There is nothing wrong with their performances, it's just where did all the actors go? Morgan Freeman plays his usual old, father-figure in charge. I only have two complaints about this film. First, most movies that have the President as a hostage seem to think the rest of the government would just lie down and capitulate. They seem to forget that we have continuity in command in our government. While we do not relish the idea of our chief executive as a hostage, we are not a dictatorship or monarchy. Our society and government will go on. The terrorists at one point make ridiculous demands and the government just gives in to save the President. This would never happen. I realize it is just a movie, but there are limits to my disbelief. The other is that director Antoine Fuquoi shoots most of the movie in the dark, so it is difficult to see what is going on and therefore the action tends to be confusing. Also, since it is confusing, it tends to not be very exciting.
So, overall, it is a fine romp, but it is not exactly a masterpiece.
Twilight
1.5 Stars (Out of four)
"I never gave much thought to how I would die. But dying for someone you love, that's not such a bad way to go."
So begins the cinematic rendition of the modern tale Twilight, which, if sales are to believed, is the 7th best selling book of all time. Let's start with my biases straight off when I started this film. First, I love vampire myths in many forms, particularly Bram Stoker's and Anne Rice's. Dracula and Lestat rank up there as some of the most interesting literary characters ever created. When Interview With The Vampire came out and I heard Tom Cruise would be Lestat, I was aghast and dead set against it. But it surprised me with how good it was, and now I love it. I have been proved wrong before when I hated an idea. Now, I have tried to read this book, that so many starry-eyed young (and not so young) girls have swooned over. I wanted to see what the big deal was about. I tried, valiantly, to finish the book. I never got beyond 100 pages, and even that was torture. The main heroine, Bella, is a whiny, stuck-up little brat who incessantly complains and moans about her situation. She hates the little town she's in. She hates the stupid little people who are around her and acts above them, even though she has crippling self-doubt of her own. This narrative goes on and on for about 70 pages; poor little me, I hate my life. Then she meets Edward Cullen, an impossibly beautiful boy vampire and his impossibly beautiful vampire family with impossibly beautiful vampiric manners and impossibly beautiful vampire features and impossibly beautiful blah blah blah. If you think I am exaggerating, Stephanie Meyers comes up with more ways to describe how beautiful Edward is than the great poets have described their greatest and unrequited loves. That's about as far as I got. I couldn't take it any more. I realize I am not the target audience for this book, but it was just too painful. So before anyone says, and a few have already, that the movie is not a fair representation of the book; well, it is not a good advocate for this picture, either.
Now, that said, how is the movie? It has remarkable faults, but it is not horrible. The worst insult that I can honestly throw at it is that it is not a bomb, it it's pretty dumb. The first half took some slogging through, but it got moderately interesting in the end. Why it took so long to get good, I'll never know, but there it is. So what is wrong with it? Let's start with everything. Ie neuters the vampire myth. It is the feel-good, PETA-approved version of vampires. The good ones don't prey on humans, only animals. Vegetarians, as Edward says in the movie. Vampires after all, are not perfect predators who drink blood from humans, the are misunderstood, brooding poets at heart. After all, don't lions and sharks eat tofu and garden burgers as well? Even Bella is a vegetarian, which we see multiple times with her diet and constant badgering of the other characters in the movie on their eating habits. So why shouldn't the perfect killing machines be vegans, too? This, to me, is an annoying trait behind a lot of these so-called romantic stories. They pick particularly gruesome subject matter as their backdrops, but conveniently forget the horror around them. Antony and Cleopatra? Two slimy schemers who got what they deserved in the midst of a horrible civil war. Romeo and Juliet? A fourteen and seventeen year old whose rash affair results in the death of seven people, including their own lives by suicide, and plunge their families to even more none-stop feuding. And now, Edward and Bella. But love triumphs over all, no matter how much it affects those around them, right?
Next, for a great love story, I have never seen two protagonists more intent on being uncomfortable around each other than these two. The movie should have been renamed Twilight: The Awkward Pause. The whole movie is nothing but one awkward situation after another, punctuated by stale, chick-flick cliches occasionally. I like a good love story, but these two seem to be constantly uncomfortable in each other's presence. Now before you all say, wait a minute, this is only the first chapter. Their love grows and blossoms and matures into this incredible, passionate romance. Well, I say, this is a movie. Oscar Wilde said brevity is the soul of wit. In other words, don't waste my damn time. The movie clocks in at over two hours. Casablanca, another great love story, tells of a more satisfying relationship in just under an hour and a half. Get on with it! And while we are on the subject of the most blasé love affair of all time, let's talk about the leads, Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson. There is absolutely no chemistry between them whatsoever. This is not the actors' fault, i think. I have seen them in other films and they are both competent actors in some of the other roles they have played. They just suck (no pun intended), in this one. They fall in love because the script says so. Never once did I feel any passion in their performance. If you want me to believe that an extremely introverted, shy girl is desperately in love with a monster, impossibly beautiful as he may be, it needs to come through. There is no thunderbolt from the blue. Just, hey, he's the best looking one here in the cast, he must be my true love.
Now, acting. I know Kristen Stewart can be a good actress. I've seen it. She was great as rocker Joan Jett in The Runaways. But in this film, there is nothing but boredom. Bella is narrating the picture and she sounds bored. She starts off with the hackneyed quote above, and it never gets any better. Harrison Ford famously monotonously read his narration in Blade Runnet, because he thought the tacked-on narration was stupid and redundant and he hoped they wouldn't use it. So what is Stewart's excuse? Her face throughout most of the film made me think she was severely constipated. I guess that goes right along with the movie's theme of discomfort. She doesn't act like a person desperately in love, rather like someone who took three Xanax 20 minutes before she goes to sleep. Even when she finally does wake up at the end, she is constantly blubbering and can't get a straight thought out. I don't think this is her fault, but rather that of the dirctor's. One of the director's biggest jobs in the film is to coax a good performance from their actors. Remember, this was before Kristen Stewart was a star from these movies. You think there would have been some incentive to wow us and not to phone it in. She has the capability, unless the movie I spoke of was a fluke. This is a passionate love story. I saw neither passion nor love. There's nothing particularly wrong with Pattinson's performance except that he, too, seems oddly dispassionate to his "particular brand of heroin" as he describes Bella. Doesn't that just make your heart melt ladies? I realize he is wrestling with his nature, but I just don't buy he is in love. He spends more time trying to push her away then going after what he really wants. That doesn't communicate love to me, but nausea. I can only conclude that the problem is, like all bad movies fundamentally, that the script is flawed.
Also, what about the supporting characters? Anyone other than Bella or Edward has the thankless job of propelling our two heroes into the next situation. There are some interesting possibilities. Her mother and father divorced, but semi-amicably it seems. Edward's family, why would vampires hide in a small community year after year after year? There seems to be an issue with their safety, but they keep coming back. Edward, who is at least 100 years old, acts like a seventeen-year-old the whole movie. He does not act like a being who has over 109 years of accumulated knowledge. What is the point of Jacob, her well-meaninged native-American friend? Bella's teenaged friends actually have some depth and are not cardboard cutouts. Yet we know so very little about any of them, almost to the point of frustration. All of these people have interesting situations and none of them get their fair due. We are introduced to the bad vampires, a trio of killers. Again, none of them do anything interesting. However, the actors who play them fall into the same trap that many actors do who play vampires. They act like they are Victorian aristocracy with bad British accents and scenery-chewing over-emoting.
But there is some good in this film. It gets mildly interesting when one of the bad vampires decides to hunt Bella and try to kill her. The Cullen family, who initially distrust her, rise up and defend her. But in the end, it isn't enough to save this turkey from its own dumbness. The sad thing is, this could have been a good flick. I love all sorts of vampire stories: Dracula, Interview With The Vampire, The Lost Boys, Near Dark, Underworld. But this is merely a dumb, love story written by someone who has never contemplated immortality and the curse it would be.
"I never gave much thought to how I would die. But dying for someone you love, that's not such a bad way to go."
So begins the cinematic rendition of the modern tale Twilight, which, if sales are to believed, is the 7th best selling book of all time. Let's start with my biases straight off when I started this film. First, I love vampire myths in many forms, particularly Bram Stoker's and Anne Rice's. Dracula and Lestat rank up there as some of the most interesting literary characters ever created. When Interview With The Vampire came out and I heard Tom Cruise would be Lestat, I was aghast and dead set against it. But it surprised me with how good it was, and now I love it. I have been proved wrong before when I hated an idea. Now, I have tried to read this book, that so many starry-eyed young (and not so young) girls have swooned over. I wanted to see what the big deal was about. I tried, valiantly, to finish the book. I never got beyond 100 pages, and even that was torture. The main heroine, Bella, is a whiny, stuck-up little brat who incessantly complains and moans about her situation. She hates the little town she's in. She hates the stupid little people who are around her and acts above them, even though she has crippling self-doubt of her own. This narrative goes on and on for about 70 pages; poor little me, I hate my life. Then she meets Edward Cullen, an impossibly beautiful boy vampire and his impossibly beautiful vampire family with impossibly beautiful vampiric manners and impossibly beautiful vampire features and impossibly beautiful blah blah blah. If you think I am exaggerating, Stephanie Meyers comes up with more ways to describe how beautiful Edward is than the great poets have described their greatest and unrequited loves. That's about as far as I got. I couldn't take it any more. I realize I am not the target audience for this book, but it was just too painful. So before anyone says, and a few have already, that the movie is not a fair representation of the book; well, it is not a good advocate for this picture, either.
Now, that said, how is the movie? It has remarkable faults, but it is not horrible. The worst insult that I can honestly throw at it is that it is not a bomb, it it's pretty dumb. The first half took some slogging through, but it got moderately interesting in the end. Why it took so long to get good, I'll never know, but there it is. So what is wrong with it? Let's start with everything. Ie neuters the vampire myth. It is the feel-good, PETA-approved version of vampires. The good ones don't prey on humans, only animals. Vegetarians, as Edward says in the movie. Vampires after all, are not perfect predators who drink blood from humans, the are misunderstood, brooding poets at heart. After all, don't lions and sharks eat tofu and garden burgers as well? Even Bella is a vegetarian, which we see multiple times with her diet and constant badgering of the other characters in the movie on their eating habits. So why shouldn't the perfect killing machines be vegans, too? This, to me, is an annoying trait behind a lot of these so-called romantic stories. They pick particularly gruesome subject matter as their backdrops, but conveniently forget the horror around them. Antony and Cleopatra? Two slimy schemers who got what they deserved in the midst of a horrible civil war. Romeo and Juliet? A fourteen and seventeen year old whose rash affair results in the death of seven people, including their own lives by suicide, and plunge their families to even more none-stop feuding. And now, Edward and Bella. But love triumphs over all, no matter how much it affects those around them, right?
Next, for a great love story, I have never seen two protagonists more intent on being uncomfortable around each other than these two. The movie should have been renamed Twilight: The Awkward Pause. The whole movie is nothing but one awkward situation after another, punctuated by stale, chick-flick cliches occasionally. I like a good love story, but these two seem to be constantly uncomfortable in each other's presence. Now before you all say, wait a minute, this is only the first chapter. Their love grows and blossoms and matures into this incredible, passionate romance. Well, I say, this is a movie. Oscar Wilde said brevity is the soul of wit. In other words, don't waste my damn time. The movie clocks in at over two hours. Casablanca, another great love story, tells of a more satisfying relationship in just under an hour and a half. Get on with it! And while we are on the subject of the most blasé love affair of all time, let's talk about the leads, Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson. There is absolutely no chemistry between them whatsoever. This is not the actors' fault, i think. I have seen them in other films and they are both competent actors in some of the other roles they have played. They just suck (no pun intended), in this one. They fall in love because the script says so. Never once did I feel any passion in their performance. If you want me to believe that an extremely introverted, shy girl is desperately in love with a monster, impossibly beautiful as he may be, it needs to come through. There is no thunderbolt from the blue. Just, hey, he's the best looking one here in the cast, he must be my true love.
Now, acting. I know Kristen Stewart can be a good actress. I've seen it. She was great as rocker Joan Jett in The Runaways. But in this film, there is nothing but boredom. Bella is narrating the picture and she sounds bored. She starts off with the hackneyed quote above, and it never gets any better. Harrison Ford famously monotonously read his narration in Blade Runnet, because he thought the tacked-on narration was stupid and redundant and he hoped they wouldn't use it. So what is Stewart's excuse? Her face throughout most of the film made me think she was severely constipated. I guess that goes right along with the movie's theme of discomfort. She doesn't act like a person desperately in love, rather like someone who took three Xanax 20 minutes before she goes to sleep. Even when she finally does wake up at the end, she is constantly blubbering and can't get a straight thought out. I don't think this is her fault, but rather that of the dirctor's. One of the director's biggest jobs in the film is to coax a good performance from their actors. Remember, this was before Kristen Stewart was a star from these movies. You think there would have been some incentive to wow us and not to phone it in. She has the capability, unless the movie I spoke of was a fluke. This is a passionate love story. I saw neither passion nor love. There's nothing particularly wrong with Pattinson's performance except that he, too, seems oddly dispassionate to his "particular brand of heroin" as he describes Bella. Doesn't that just make your heart melt ladies? I realize he is wrestling with his nature, but I just don't buy he is in love. He spends more time trying to push her away then going after what he really wants. That doesn't communicate love to me, but nausea. I can only conclude that the problem is, like all bad movies fundamentally, that the script is flawed.
Also, what about the supporting characters? Anyone other than Bella or Edward has the thankless job of propelling our two heroes into the next situation. There are some interesting possibilities. Her mother and father divorced, but semi-amicably it seems. Edward's family, why would vampires hide in a small community year after year after year? There seems to be an issue with their safety, but they keep coming back. Edward, who is at least 100 years old, acts like a seventeen-year-old the whole movie. He does not act like a being who has over 109 years of accumulated knowledge. What is the point of Jacob, her well-meaninged native-American friend? Bella's teenaged friends actually have some depth and are not cardboard cutouts. Yet we know so very little about any of them, almost to the point of frustration. All of these people have interesting situations and none of them get their fair due. We are introduced to the bad vampires, a trio of killers. Again, none of them do anything interesting. However, the actors who play them fall into the same trap that many actors do who play vampires. They act like they are Victorian aristocracy with bad British accents and scenery-chewing over-emoting.
But there is some good in this film. It gets mildly interesting when one of the bad vampires decides to hunt Bella and try to kill her. The Cullen family, who initially distrust her, rise up and defend her. But in the end, it isn't enough to save this turkey from its own dumbness. The sad thing is, this could have been a good flick. I love all sorts of vampire stories: Dracula, Interview With The Vampire, The Lost Boys, Near Dark, Underworld. But this is merely a dumb, love story written by someone who has never contemplated immortality and the curse it would be.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)







